Menu
Menu
The imperfect boss

The imperfect boss

Three CIOs debate whether a CIO should report to the CEO or the CFO

At a recent CIO Perspectives conference, I sat in on an interesting session. On stage three CIOs debated the topic of reporting relationships. The crux of their discussion: should a CIO report to the CEO or the CFO? The consensus seemed to be that it is much better for a CIO to report directly to the CEO (or COO). At companies where the CIO reports to the CEO, information technology is viewed as an investment. No one argued for a reporting relationship to the CFO because panellists claimed those companies that have one see IT as a cost to be managed, curtailed or cut.

The argument seems logical. But earlier this year I presented readers with seven creeds of the CEO as a way to characterise how their CEO views IT. (The creeds were originally defined in a Sloan Management Review article.) I asked readers to select the category that most represents the CEO at their company and vote on CIO’s website. The results may surprise you. They certainly surprised me.

CIO.com poll on CEO types

The category that best represents the CEO at your company:

27% The Hypocrite, who espouses strategic importance of IT but negates belief through personal action.

19% The Believer, who believes IT enables strategic advantage and demonstrates belief through action.

18% The Waverer, who reluctantly accepts strategic importance of IT.

14% The Monarch, who accepts IT is important, appoints the best CIO and steps back.

11% The Agnostic, who concedes IT is important but needs repeated convincing.

8% The Zealot, who is convinced IT is important and equally believes he is an IT expert.

2% The Atheist, who is convinced IT is of little value and publicly espouses this belief.

Total number of respondents: 159. Numbers do not add up to 100% due to rounding.

Well, so much for the theory that reporting to the CEO is better than reporting to the CFO.

Leading IT in your company is your responsibility. Take on that responsibility with passion and enthusiasm every day you report to work regardless of whom you call boss.

And thanks to those readers who took the time to vote.

Gary Beach is publisher of CIO US. He can be reached at gary_beach@cio.com.

Join the CIO New Zealand group on LinkedIn. The group is open to CIOs, IT Directors, COOs, CTOs and senior IT managers.

Join the newsletter!

Error: Please check your email address.
Show Comments

Market Place